|
| 1 | +# Rejected owned server mesh batches (#4066) |
| 2 | + |
| 3 | +The candidate transferred non-retained mesh batches into the existing server |
| 4 | +channel instead of cloning their owned buffers. It used the same canonical |
| 5 | +processing loop and preserved the borrowed API, retained output, batch/progress |
| 6 | +boundaries, styling and cancellation. It was rejected by the prespecified actual |
| 7 | +HTTP continuation rule. No production implementation or wider corpus run landed. |
| 8 | + |
| 9 | +[screen.json](screen.json) contains every arm of the initial three-model screen, |
| 10 | +its exact gates, separate startup/readiness clocks, sampled RSS, continuation |
| 11 | +rule, source/artifact/compiler identities and validation limits. The small model |
| 12 | +and MEP model were slower in their single pairs; the largest model improved |
| 13 | +modestly while its sampled RSS increased. These observations neither establish |
| 14 | +precise causal contributions nor justify a general claim that ownership transfer |
| 15 | +cannot help. Removing a real copy does not by itself establish an end-to-end win. |
| 16 | + |
| 17 | +All three models passed the declared complete semantic witness, strict raw |
| 18 | +geometry/data-model comparisons, actual hash-only cache replay and cleanup gates. |
| 19 | +No diagnostic mismatch was waived. The primary clock ends when complete SSE and |
| 20 | +data-model receipt both finish; startup is separate. This is HTTP qualification, |
| 21 | +not browser readiness or physical-footprint evidence. Every offline decode and |
| 22 | +retention operation occurred after both timed arms. The isolated verifier reused |
| 23 | +only complete byte-equal inputs with validated witness/version identities; |
| 24 | +current completion and transport fields were independently checked. |
| 25 | + |
| 26 | +The workspace tests and strict workspace/all-target Clippy passed on the exact |
| 27 | +candidate. Downloaded external fixtures were absent: the preserved test evidence |
| 28 | +records ignored tests and fixture-skip messages. Inline/committed-fixture tests |
| 29 | +exercise ownership, both APIs, retained output, styling/progress/bootstrap |
| 30 | +sequences and cancellation. They complement the actual HTTP cases and are not a |
| 31 | +substitute for corpus qualification. |
| 32 | + |
| 33 | +## Reproduce the rejected source |
| 34 | + |
| 35 | +[measured-candidate.patch](measured-candidate.patch) archives the complete local |
| 36 | +candidate, including its tests and Rust API documentation. It uses zero-context |
| 37 | +full-index Git format so patch-context blank lines do not trigger the repository |
| 38 | +whitespace gate. In an isolated checkout at the public base recorded in |
| 39 | +[source-archive.json](source-archive.json), run: |
| 40 | + |
| 41 | +```sh |
| 42 | +git apply --unidiff-zero /path/to/measured-candidate.patch |
| 43 | +``` |
| 44 | + |
| 45 | +Temporary-index application reconstructed the **exact measured candidate tree**. |
| 46 | +The public base's Rust/server/Cargo source also matches the measured control. |
| 47 | +The archive records these identities and the patch digest; applying it is not a |
| 48 | +new build or performance measurement. The candidate used the same pinned |
| 49 | +compiler, explicit standard-library build configuration, target and release |
| 50 | +profile as the control, with no PGO inputs. |
| 51 | + |
| 52 | +Raw captures and complete private logs remain retained; repository evidence |
| 53 | +contains sanitized measurements and their hash references, not those large |
| 54 | +payloads. Exact duplicate evidence files share APFS extents while retaining |
| 55 | +separate paths and inodes. No unique raw evidence was removed. |
0 commit comments