Skip to content

Make enums derived from uint16_t at least or migrate to libfmt, to avoid garbled log in OPENRAVE_ASSERT_OP #1365

@cielavenir

Description

@cielavenir

Today I read boost::format source code and it turned out that it was just a frontend of stringstream (eg boost::str(boost::format("%x") % "xyz") is the same as std::cout << std::setbase(16) << "xyz" << std::endl;).

ostream, including stringstream, handles uint8_t in the same way as char ( cf https://cplusplus.com/reference/ostream/basic_ostream/operator-free/ ).

Recently openrave changed some enums derived from uint8_t ( d841c76 ). It is problematic when the values are directly passed to OPENRAVE_ASSERT_OP because if the assertion fails, boost::format is called, and the value are printed as char, which is unexpected and garbled.
We paid some attention to pass the value with casting to int, but it is forgettable ( eg planningcommon https://tiny.mujin.co.jp/mcyzo ).
To avoid further confusion, enums should be derived from uint16_t at least.
Alternatively I suggest to migrate to libfmt ( we discussed this years ago https://tiny.mujin.co.jp/czkx4 ), which does not have this uint8_t output issue.

/cc @ntohge

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

No labels
No labels

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions