Skip to content

Wrong Execution Result using frontier hardfork #222

New issue
New issue
Open
#223
Open
Wrong Execution Result using frontier hardfork#222
#223
@Lohann

Description

@Lohann
Lohann
opened on Nov 20, 2023

Crate version: v0.41.0

I was using this evm for syncing to ethereum mainnet, as sanity check I computed the state root using the VM and compared it against the expected state root, whoever I found a sync mismatch when processing this transaction at block 49018:
https://etherscan.io/tx/0x5c4fdc85bf5efdfcbf7d4991c37287a9c3d5b660b57b0082118c3cff3c69dff1

I was syncing using the correct preset Config::frontier, after a investigation I've found the cause of the issue.

Issue

The current implementation doesn't consider the pre EIP-2 contract creation behavior, I'll use this transaction as example: 0x5c4fdc85bf5efdfcbf7d4991c37287a9c3d5b660b57b0082118c3cff3c69dff1

Actual State Changes - incorrect

Hardfork: frontier
Gas used: 145029 (which is the transaction gas_limit)
Result: ExitError::OutOfGas
Not contract created.

Trace logs 
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record Create 65304 [gas_transaction_create: 21000, zero_data_len: 145, non_zero_data_len: 643, access_list_address_len: 0, access_list_storage_len: 0, initcode_cost: 50] [Gas used: 0, Gas left: 145029]    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 79725 [Gas used: 65304, Gas left: 79725]    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 0, Gas left: 79725]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@0]: 0x0000…0060    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 3, Gas left: 79722]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@1]: 0x0000…0040    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 3 - memory_gas 9 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 6, Gas left: 79719]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode MStore: 64, 0x0000…0060    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 18, Gas left: 79707]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@0]: 0x0000…0040    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 3 - memory_gas 9 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 21, Gas left: 79704]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode MLoad: 64    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 24, Gas left: 79701]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@1]: 0x0000…02b4    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 2 [Gas used: 27, Gas left: 79698]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode CodeSize: 788    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 29, Gas left: 79696]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode overflowing_sub 788, 692: 96    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 32, Gas left: 79693]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup1 [@2]: 0x0000…0060    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 35, Gas left: 79690]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@3]: 0x0000…02b4    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 38, Gas left: 79687]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup4 [@4]: 0x0000…0060    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 12 - memory_gas 18 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 41, Gas left: 79684]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode CodeCopy: 96    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 62, Gas left: 79663]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode overflowing_add 96, 96: 192    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 65, Gas left: 79660]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@1]: 0x0000…0040    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 3 - memory_gas 18 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 68, Gas left: 79657]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode MStore: 64, 0x0000…00c0    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 71, Gas left: 79654]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@0]: 0x0000…0060    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 74, Gas left: 79651]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup1 [@1]: 0x0000…0060    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 3 - memory_gas 18 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 77, Gas left: 79648]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode MLoad: 96    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 80, Gas left: 79645]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@2]: 0x0000…0060    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 83, Gas left: 79642]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode overflowing_add 96, 32: 128    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 86, Gas left: 79639]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@1]: 0x0000…0080, 0x0000…0060    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 89, Gas left: 79636]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@2]: 0x0000…0020    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 92, Gas left: 79633]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode overflowing_add 32, 96: 128    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 2 [Gas used: 95, Gas left: 79630]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Pop [@1]: 0x0000…0080    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 1 [Gas used: 97, Gas left: 79628]    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 1 [Gas used: 98, Gas left: 79627]    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 2 [Gas used: 99, Gas left: 79626]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Trap: Opcode(51)    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 101, Gas left: 79624]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@2]: 0x0000…0000    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 104, Gas left: 79621]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@3]: 0x0000…0000    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 107, Gas left: 79618]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@4]: 0x0000…0100    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 10 - memory_gas 18 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 110, Gas left: 79615]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode self::arithmetic::exp 256, 0: 1    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 120, Gas left: 79605]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup2 [@4]: 0x0000…0000    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 50 - memory_gas 18 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 123, Gas left: 79602]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Trap: Opcode(84)    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 173, Gas left: 79552]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup2 [@5]: 0x0000…0001    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 176, Gas left: 79549]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@6]: 0x0000…ffff    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 5 [Gas used: 179, Gas left: 79546]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode overflowing_mul 1461501637330902918203684832716283019655932542975, 1: 1461501637330902918203684832716283019655932542975    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 184, Gas left: 79541]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode self::bitwise::not 1461501637330902918203684832716283019655932542975: 115792089237316195423570985007226406215939081747436879206741300988257197096960    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 187, Gas left: 79538]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode bitand 115792089237316195423570985007226406215939081747436879206741300988257197096960, 0: 0    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 190, Gas left: 79535]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@1]: 0x0000…0000, 0x0000…0001    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 193, Gas left: 79532]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup4 [@5]: 0x0000…6c2d    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 5 [Gas used: 196, Gas left: 79529]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode overflowing_mul 348413676108971912559174908100972406029277031469, 1: 348413676108971912559174908100972406029277031469    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 201, Gas left: 79524]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode bitor 348413676108971912559174908100972406029277031469, 0: 348413676108971912559174908100972406029277031469    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 204, Gas left: 79521]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@1]: 0x0000…6c2d, 0x0000…0000    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 20000 - memory_gas 18 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 207, Gas left: 79518]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Trap: Opcode(85)    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 2 [Gas used: 20207, Gas left: 59518]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Pop [@1]: 0x0000…6c2d    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 1 [Gas used: 20209, Gas left: 59516]    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 20210, Gas left: 59515]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup1 [@1]: 0x0000…0080    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 20213, Gas left: 59512]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@2]: 0x0000…0001    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 20216, Gas left: 59509]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@3]: 0x0000…0000    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 2 [Gas used: 20219, Gas left: 59506]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Pop [@3]: 0x0000…0000    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 20221, Gas left: 59504]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@1]: 0x0000…0001, 0x0000…0080    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 20224, Gas left: 59501]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup1 [@3]: 0x0000…0080    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 3 - memory_gas 18 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 20227, Gas left: 59498]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode MLoad: 128    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 20230, Gas left: 59495]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@1]: 0x0000…000c, 0x0000…0080    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 20233, Gas left: 59492]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@4]: 0x0000…0020    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 20236, Gas left: 59489]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode overflowing_add 32, 128: 160    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 20239, Gas left: 59486]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@1]: 0x0000…00a0, 0x0000…000c    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 20242, Gas left: 59483]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup3 [@4]: 0x0000…0001    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 20245, Gas left: 59480]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup1 [@5]: 0x0000…0001    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 50 - memory_gas 18 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 20248, Gas left: 59477]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Trap: Opcode(84)    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 20298, Gas left: 59427]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup3 [@6]: 0x0000…000c    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 20301, Gas left: 59424]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup3 [@7]: 0x0000…0001    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 20000 - memory_gas 18 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 20304, Gas left: 59421]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Trap: Opcode(85)    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40304, Gas left: 39421]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@1]: 0x0000…0000, 0x0000…0001    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40307, Gas left: 39418]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@6]: 0x0000…0000    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 3 - memory_gas 18 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 40310, Gas left: 39415]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode MStore: 0, 0x0000…0001    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40313, Gas left: 39412]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@5]: 0x0000…0020    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40316, Gas left: 39409]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@6]: 0x0000…0000    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 36 - memory_gas 18 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 40319, Gas left: 39406]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Trap: Opcode(32)    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40355, Gas left: 39370]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@1]: 0xb10e…0cf6, 0x0000…0000    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40358, Gas left: 39367]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@6]: 0x0000…001f    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40361, Gas left: 39364]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode overflowing_add 31, 0: 31    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40364, Gas left: 39361]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@6]: 0x0000…0020    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40367, Gas left: 39358]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@1]: 0x0000…0020, 0x0000…001f    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 5 [Gas used: 40370, Gas left: 39355]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode self::arithmetic::div 31, 32: 0    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40375, Gas left: 39350]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup2 [@6]: 0xb10e…0cf6    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40378, Gas left: 39347]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode overflowing_add 80084422859880547211683076133703299733277748156566366325829078699459944778998, 0: 80084422859880547211683076133703299733277748156566366325829078699459944778998    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40381, Gas left: 39344]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@3]: 0xb10e…0cf6, 0x0000…00a0    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40384, Gas left: 39341]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup3 [@6]: 0x0000…000c    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40387, Gas left: 39338]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode self::bitwise::iszero 12: 0    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40390, Gas left: 39335]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@7]: 0x0000…009e    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 10 [Gas used: 40393, Gas left: 39332]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode JumpI: skipped    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40403, Gas left: 39322]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@2]: 0x0000…00a0, 0x0000…000c    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40406, Gas left: 39319]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup3 [@6]: 0x0000…00a0    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40409, Gas left: 39316]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode overflowing_add 160, 12: 172    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 1 [Gas used: 40412, Gas left: 39313]    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40413, Gas left: 39312]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup3 [@6]: 0x0000…00a0    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40416, Gas left: 39309]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup2 [@7]: 0x0000…00ac    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40419, Gas left: 39306]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode gt 172, 160: true    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40422, Gas left: 39303]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode self::bitwise::iszero 1: 0    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40425, Gas left: 39300]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@7]: 0x0000…009d    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 10 [Gas used: 40428, Gas left: 39297]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode JumpI: skipped    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40438, Gas left: 39287]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup3 [@6]: 0x0000…00a0    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 3 - memory_gas 18 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 40441, Gas left: 39284]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode MLoad: 160    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40444, Gas left: 39281]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup3 [@7]: 0xb10e…0cf6    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 40447, Gas left: 39278]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@8]: 0x0000…0000    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 2 [Gas used: 40450, Gas left: 39275]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Pop [@8]: 0x0000…0000    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 20000 - memory_gas 18 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 40452, Gas left: 39273]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Trap: Opcode(85)    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60452, Gas left: 19273]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@2]: 0x0000…00ac, 0x0000…00a0    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60455, Gas left: 19270]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@6]: 0x0000…0020    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60458, Gas left: 19267]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode overflowing_add 32, 160: 192    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60461, Gas left: 19264]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@2]: 0x0000…00c0, 0x0000…00ac    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60464, Gas left: 19261]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@1]: 0x0000…00ac, 0xb10e…0cf6    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60467, Gas left: 19258]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@6]: 0x0000…0001    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60470, Gas left: 19255]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode overflowing_add 1, 80084422859880547211683076133703299733277748156566366325829078699459944778998: 80084422859880547211683076133703299733277748156566366325829078699459944778999    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60473, Gas left: 19252]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@1]: 0xb10e…0cf7, 0x0000…00ac    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60476, Gas left: 19249]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@6]: 0x0000…0081    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 8 [Gas used: 60479, Gas left: 19246]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Jump: 129    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 1 [Gas used: 60487, Gas left: 19238]    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60488, Gas left: 19237]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup3 [@6]: 0x0000…00c0    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60491, Gas left: 19234]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup2 [@7]: 0x0000…00ac    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60494, Gas left: 19231]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode gt 172, 192: false    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60497, Gas left: 19228]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode self::bitwise::iszero 0: 1    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60500, Gas left: 19225]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@7]: 0x0000…009d    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 10 [Gas used: 60503, Gas left: 19222]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode JumpI: 157    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 1 [Gas used: 60513, Gas left: 19212]    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 1 [Gas used: 60514, Gas left: 19211]    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 2 [Gas used: 60515, Gas left: 19210]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Pop [@5]: 0x0000…00ac    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60517, Gas left: 19208]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@1]: 0xb10e…0cf7, 0x0000…00c0    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 2 [Gas used: 60520, Gas left: 19205]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Pop [@4]: 0x0000…00c0    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60522, Gas left: 19203]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@4]: 0x0000…00c5    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60525, Gas left: 19200]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@2]: 0x0000…00c5, 0xb10e…0cf6    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60528, Gas left: 19197]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@1]: 0xb10e…0cf6, 0xb10e…0cf7    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60531, Gas left: 19194]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@5]: 0x0000…00a9    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 8 [Gas used: 60534, Gas left: 19191]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Jump: 169    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 1 [Gas used: 60542, Gas left: 19183]    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60543, Gas left: 19182]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup1 [@5]: 0xb10e…0cf7    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60546, Gas left: 19179]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup3 [@6]: 0xb10e…0cf6    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60549, Gas left: 19176]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode gt 80084422859880547211683076133703299733277748156566366325829078699459944778998, 80084422859880547211683076133703299733277748156566366325829078699459944778999: false    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60552, Gas left: 19173]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode self::bitwise::iszero 0: 1    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60555, Gas left: 19170]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@6]: 0x0000…00c1    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 10 [Gas used: 60558, Gas left: 19167]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode JumpI: 193    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 1 [Gas used: 60568, Gas left: 19157]    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 2 [Gas used: 60569, Gas left: 19156]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Pop [@4]: 0xb10e…0cf7    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60571, Gas left: 19154]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Swap [@0:@1]: 0xb10e…0cf6, 0x0000…00c5    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 8 [Gas used: 60574, Gas left: 19151]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Jump: 197    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 1 [Gas used: 60582, Gas left: 19143]    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 2 [Gas used: 60583, Gas left: 19142]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Pop [@2]: 0xb10e…0cf6    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 2 [Gas used: 60585, Gas left: 19140]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Pop [@1]: 0x0000…0001    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 1 [Gas used: 60587, Gas left: 19138]    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 2 [Gas used: 60588, Gas left: 19137]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Pop [@0]: 0x0000…0080    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60590, Gas left: 19135]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@0]: 0x0000…01dc    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60593, Gas left: 19132]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Dup1 [@1]: 0x0000…01dc    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60596, Gas left: 19129]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@2]: 0x0000…00d8    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60599, Gas left: 19126]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@3]: 0x0000…0000    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 48 - memory_gas 45 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 60602, Gas left: 19123]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode CodeCopy: 476    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 3 [Gas used: 60677, Gas left: 19048]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Push [@1]: 0x0000…0000    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record dynamic cost 0 - memory_gas 45 - gas_refund 0 [Gas used: 60680, Gas left: 19045]    
  TRACE evm: OpCode Return    
  DEBUG evm: Create execution using address 0x630e…fe7a: Succeed(Returned)    
  TRACE evm: Gasometer Record cost 95200 [Gas used: 60680, Gas left: 19045]

Expected State Changes

Hardfork: frontier
Gas used: 125984
Result: Succeed(Returned)
Empty Contract Created at 0x630ea66c8c5dc205d45a978573fa86df5af1fe7a

The difference in the execution is that if there's no gas for paying the bytecode deposit bytes.len() * 200, it must deploy an Empty Contract Account, which is the same as deploying a regular contract, but without the bytecode.

{
    "nonce": 0,
    "balance": tx.value,
    "code": [], // empty bytes
    "storage": {
        "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000": "0x0000000000000000000000003d0768da09ce77d25e2d998e6a7b6ed4b9116c2d",
        "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001": "0x000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000c",
        "0xb10e2d527612073b26eecdfd717e6a320cf44b4afac2b0732d9fcbe2b7fa0cf6": "0x48656c6c6f20576f726c64210000000000000000000000000000000000000000"
    },
}

For compute the state root I'm using this crate: https://docs.rs/trie-root/latest/trie_root/

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions